Treehouses Require Dwelling Permits
False Assumption: Small backyard treehouses must obtain building permits equivalent to those for single-family dwellings, including architectural plans and geological reports.
Written by FARAgent on February 11, 2026
In 2000, Simpsons producer Rick Polizzi built a 110-square-foot treehouse in his Sherman Oaks front yard for his daughters, modeled on the show's Treehouse of Horror. It expanded into Boney Island, an animatronic Halloween display drawing crowds from across Los Angeles. Popularity overwhelmed the neighborhood, so Polizzi relocated it to Griffith Park and the Natural History Museum.
Neighbors continued visiting Polizzi's home on Halloween, prompting complaints to the City of Los Angeles. The city demanded permits, classifying the treehouse as a single-family dwelling requiring structural plans, geological reports, and other approvals costing $30,000 to $40,000. Polizzi spent $40,000 fighting citations and criminal charges over seven years.
After a pre-trial hearing, Polizzi surrendered. The city ordered demolition of the landmark structure. LA, a city built on creativity, chose bureaucratic enforcement over preserving a community treasure.
People Involved
- Rick Polizzi, a three-time Emmy-winning producer for The Simpsons, built a backyard treehouse in Los Angeles as a gift to his neighborhood. He turned it into Boney Island, a free Halloween attraction that drew crowds for years. City officials targeted him starting around 2018, treating him as a scofflaw rather than a benefactor. He fought back in court but faced criminal charges over permit disputes. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“Rick Polizzi, a former producer of the sitcom... winner of three Emmys.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
Organizations Involved
The City of Los Angeles enforced strict zoning rules against the treehouse through its Department of Building and Safety. Officials classified the 110-square-foot structure as a full dwelling, demanding extensive permits. The municipal government waged a seven-year legal battle to tear it down, ignoring its role as a community landmark. Institutional priorities favored rigid compliance over local goodwill. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“LADBS requires him to follow guidelines for a single-family dwelling, he said. 'They are also requiring architectural & structural plans, geological reports, etc. which could cost us another $30K to $40K,' he wrote.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
“An iconic California treehouse inspired by the Simpsons is set to be demolished following a seven-year legal battle between the city and its owner.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
The Foundation
Los Angeles zoning laws treated small treehouses like single-family homes, requiring architectural plans and geological reports. This seemed reasonable for safety reasons at first. Yet it burdened harmless play structures with high costs. The city approved zoning in December 2023 but still insisted on unmet dwelling-level permits. The assumption held because bureaucrats stuck to the letter of the code, even when it made no sense. In the end, it was wrong. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“Although the structure is a 110-square-foot treehouse, LADBS requires him to follow guidelines for a single-family dwelling, he said.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
“The three-time Emmy winning producer was granted zoning administration approval for his treehouse in December 2023, but has not yet obtained a permit.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
How It Spread
Neighbor complaints about Halloween crowds prompted the city to crack down around 2018. Officials cited permit violations to justify enforcement. The idea spread through municipal channels, with inspectors and lawyers reinforcing the dwelling classification. Social pressure from a few residents amplified the scrutiny, turning a festive spot into a regulatory target. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“Neighbors complained to the city of LA the home drew too much attention as people from all over come to see the treehouse, especially during Halloween.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
Resulting Policies
Los Angeles zoning policies, tightened in recent decades, forced Rick Polizzi to submit detailed architectural plans and geological reports for his treehouse permit. The process began around 2018 and mirrored requirements for actual homes. These rules led to steep compliance costs, far beyond what a backyard play area warranted. Bureaucrats applied them without exception, escalating a minor issue into a major ordeal. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“'They say I don't have the right permit for it, but I've been trying to make the treehouse legal forever. The city's just not having it,' Polizzi told KTLA5.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
“I can provide a free geological report: “Yeah, when The Big One knocks down Los Angeles, his treehouse will, indeed, probably fall out of his tree and put a big divot in his lawn.””— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
Harm Caused
Rick Polizzi spent $40,000 on legal fees to save the treehouse. He faced criminal charges and watched as the city ordered its demolition. The loss erased a beloved community landmark that had entertained families for free. In a city built on entertainment, the action crushed local creativity and deprived neighborhoods of a harmless tradition. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“Polizzi has shelled out about $40,000 to help protect the structure from being taken down... Along with the slew of legal costs, the treehouse debacle has also led to criminal charges.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
“'This is a town built on creativity. It embraces it. It just seems like you would want to keep things like this up,' he added.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
Downfall
The assumption crumbled under its own weight, widely recognized now as false. Rick Polizzi gave up after a pre-trial hearing last month, letting the city claim victory and demolish the structure. The seven-year fight exposed the overreach, but not before the damage was done. Experts who enforced it looked foolish in hindsight. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“After attending a pre-trial hearing last month, Polizzi made the heartbreaking decision to let the city win and tear the treehouse down.”— City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horror
Sources
-
[1]
City of Los Angeles to tear down Treehouse of Horrorreputable_journalism