Transgenderism Reveals True Inner Self
False Assumption: Sudden transgender and nonbinary identifications among youth represent authentic innate gender identities finally freed for expression.
Written by FARAgent on February 10, 2026
In the early 2010s, as societal acceptance of diverse gender identities grew, experts and advocates began promoting the idea that the sudden surge in transgender and nonbinary identifications among youth reflected authentic, innate selves finally emerging. Psychologist Jean M. Twenge noted the rapid rise, linking it to generational shifts, while proponents like New York Times columnist Masha Gessen and ACLU attorney Chase Strangio argued that teens possessed unquestionable self-knowledge of their gender, akin to innate traits. Admiral Rachel Levine, a Biden administration official, echoed this view, framing transitions as liberating true identities from the wrong bodies. The assumption gained traction in media and policy, with supporters citing reduced stigma as the key enabler.
By the mid-2020s, cracks appeared. Identifications spiked among teenage girls, often in clusters suggesting social contagion, leading to regrets and detransitions. Aggressive activism, sometimes led by figures critics described as embodying toxic traits, fueled backlash. In 2024, researcher Eric Kaufmann reported a striking decline in the trend, attributing it to fading cultural hype. Harms mounted, including medical interventions on vulnerable youth who later questioned their paths.
Growing evidence now suggests the assumption was flawed, with researchers increasingly recognizing the surge as a generational fad rather than timeless self-discovery. Critics point to parallels with past youth trends, though the debate continues amid lingering support for innate identity narratives.
People Involved
- Jean M. Twenge, a psychologist, examined survey data in 2024. She found transgender identifications among young adults had dropped sharply. This supported her view that the trend was a passing fad. [1]
- Eric Kaufmann had predicted this decline earlier that year. He called it a striking fall in the transgender and nonbinary fad. Twenge's work confirmed his stance. [1]
- M. Gessen, a columnist at the New York Times, pushed the idea in an op-ed. Gessen compared teenage transgender self-knowledge to innate traits like being gay or Jewish. [2]
- Chase Strangio, an ACLU attorney, argued against Tennessee's ban on youth treatments in the Supreme Court. Strangio presented as a proponent of authentic gender identities. [2]
- Admiral Rachel Levine backed the trans position from the Biden Administration. Commenters at the New York Times criticized this support. [2]
- Ray Blanchard, a professor at the University of Toronto, developed the concept of autogynephilia in the 1980s. He based it on studies of patients seeking sex changes. Blanchard has long warned that opposition to his theory stems from ideology. [3]
- Julia Serano, a trans author, rejected Blanchard's model. She claimed it rested on flawed data and undermined trans identities. [3]
- Anne Lawrence, a transgender clinician, endorsed Blanchard's ideas. Lawrence saw autogynephilia as a sexual orientation in late-transitioning trans women. [3]
- Mike White, creator of The White Lotus, depicted an autogynephilic character in season three. The role went to actor Sam Rockwell and challenged media norms on trans motivations. [3]
▶ Supporting Quotes (9)
“Psychologist Jean M. Twenge, one of the leading researchers into the rise and fall of fads that sweep generations, says a second data source vindicates Eric Kaufman’s assertion last week that the transgender/nonbinary fad declined strikingly in 2024.”— Transmania: From Fad to Cringe
“Psychologist Jean M. Twenge, one of the leading researchers into the rise and fall of fads that sweep generations, says a second data source vindicates Eric Kaufman’s assertion last week that the transgender/nonbinary fad declined strikingly in 2024.”— Transmania: From Fad to Cringe
“Imagine you are a transgender teenager. Don’t ask me how you know that you are transgender: That question is no more appropriate or relevant than asking people how they know that they are gay or Jewish or Black.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“their ex-woman lead attorney Chase Strangio.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“the 42 most popular comments in the New York Times are against the trans movement, the Biden Administration, Admiral Rachel Levine, the ACLU, and/or their ex-woman lead attorney Chase Strangio.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“Blanchard theorized that some trans women — those assigned male at birth — experience sexual arousal at the idea of themselves as female, positing that gender transition in these cases is driven by an erotic fixation rather than an innate gender identity or sense of being "born in the wrong body."”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
“"Blanchard's model is built upon a number of incorrect and unfounded assumptions, and the data he offers to support it is deeply flawed due to methodological errors and biases," Serano writes in “The Case Against Autogynephilia,””— "White Lotus" dares to go there
“Lawrence said she agrees with Blanchard's classification of two primary types of trans women: those who are exclusively attracted to men and transition early in life ... and those who experience AGP and typically transition later.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
“Mike White has constructed for Rockwell an over-the-top portrayal of a stereotypical autogynephilic ex-man — intelligent, self-centered, sex-crazed, and ruthless — which is fairly novel in America media during the ongoing World War T.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
Organizations Involved
The ACLU took the lead in challenging Tennessee's ban on gender treatments for minors. The organization argued before the Supreme Court that such laws ignored authentic youth identities. [2] The Biden Administration joined the fight against state restrictions. It promoted the view that medical transitions freed innate gender selves. [2] The New York Times advanced the assumption through opinion pieces. These articles criticized the Supreme Court's skepticism as a failure to grasp transgender reality. [2] The same newspaper avoided mentioning autogynephilia in its coverage of The White Lotus. It described a key scene vaguely, despite the show's direct portrayal. [3] Other prestige press outlets followed suit. They covered the series extensively but omitted discussions of autogynephilia, maintaining silence on certain trans motivations. [3]
▶ Supporting Quotes (5)
“the 42 most popular comments in the New York Times are against the trans movement, the Biden Administration, Admiral Rachel Levine, the ACLU, and/or their ex-woman lead attorney Chase Strangio.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“the 42 most popular comments in the New York Times are against the trans movement, the Biden Administration, Admiral Rachel Levine, the ACLU, and/or their ex-woman lead attorney Chase Strangio.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“Even NYT commenters are happy.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“The New York Times, for instance, which traditionally determines what News Is Fit to Print for the rest of the prestige press, has still not mentioned the word “autogynephilia” in the 2020s”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
“it gets blanket coverage in the prestige press. For instance, today, following the weekend’s season finale, the front page of NYTimes.com links to articles about The White Lotus ten times. But, the NYT refuses to mention a certain forbidden word”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
The Foundation
The assumption gained traction around 2013 to 2015. Few people over 40 claimed transgender identities then. This suggested youth were uncovering innate truths long suppressed. Growing evidence now suggests this view was flawed, as the trend stayed limited to younger ages, resembling a fad. [1] Proponents equated teenage transgender knowledge to fixed traits like sexuality or ethnicity. They argued this justified medical steps without deep scrutiny. Analogies to cases like Rachel Dolezal later highlighted potential weaknesses in this reasoning. [2] Backers often pointed to ideas of innate gender identity or wrong-body births. High-profile transitions, such as Bruce Jenner's, bolstered this narrative. Increasingly, critics note how this overlooked male-specific factors like autogynephilia, applying a misleading uniformity to all cases, including teenage girls. [3]
▶ Supporting Quotes (3)
“When transmania took off in 2013-2015, very few people over 40 said, “Yes, finally! I now have the freedom to tell the world whom I’ve always been deep inside, a broad-shouldered 6’3” lady in a frock!” Nah, the craze was pretty much restricted to the callower, more naive, fashion victim ages.”— Transmania: From Fad to Cringe
“That would be as inappropriate as black women doubting that Rachel Dolezal is black.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“You know, much of this trans stuff we’ve been promoting so heavily is just a weird male sex fetish that has absolutely no application to you. Don’t assume that just because Bruce Jenner announces he’s a woman that the cause of your pubescent unhappiness is that you might really be a boy.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
How It Spread
Transmania took off during the Great Awokening era. It spread quickly through junior high schools. Youth adopted it as a generational trend. [1] The New York Times helped propagate the idea. Opinion pieces framed Supreme Court doubts as ignorance of transgender truths. [2] For twelve years starting in 2013, prestige media concealed the autogynephilia concept. This left moody teenage girls uninformed about motivations in prominent male transitions. Coverage portrayed trans people uniformly as virtuous without scientific depth. [3] Cancel culture reinforced the silence. Autogynephilic activists targeted those discussing related science. They went after interviewers of J. Michael Bailey, who had promoted a book on Blanchard's findings. [3]
▶ Supporting Quotes (4)
“The transmania that swept junior high schools during the Great Awokening is rapidly becoming cringe.”— Transmania: From Fad to Cringe
“The Supreme Court’s Blindness to Transgender Reality.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“Even though a large fraction of the most aggressive trans activists suffer from the autogynephilia fetish, the media over the last dozen years of transmania has kept hidden the entire concept of AGP from moody teenage girls, the main victims of trans social contagion.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
“I first tangled with them a couple of decades ago when a few very high IQ academics teamed up with the money-crazed Southern Poverty Law Center and tried to cancel anybody who’d interviewed Northwestern psychology professor J. Michael Bailey”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
Resulting Policies
Tennessee passed a law in the early 2020s banning gender-affirming procedures for minors. The state called it protection against mutilation and poisoning. Federal challenges rested on the assumption of authentic youth identities. [2] Since 2013, activists and media reframed transgenderism as a political cause. They emphasized innate narratives and downplayed clinical aspects like autogynephilia. This shift influenced public discourse and policy debates. [3]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“The Supreme Court has upheld 6-3 Tennessee’s ban on sexual mutilation and poisoning of children.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“the Trans push got going in 2013. After all, the Trans are, as we all know, the Good People, and skeptics about them are therefore the Bad People.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
Harm Caused
Transmania ranked among the more foolish trends in junior high history. Growing evidence suggests it caused social harm as youth followed the fad. [1] Teenage girls faced contagion into trans identities. They lacked knowledge that many male transitions involved a fetish irrelevant to them. This led to avoidable distress. [3] Aggressive activists, often embodying toxic traits, led cancel efforts. They ruined careers of those sharing autogynephilia research. [3]
▶ Supporting Quotes (3)
“Not too surprisingly, one of the stupidest junior high school trends ever, transgenderism, is finally falling out of fashion.”— Transmania: From Fad to Cringe
“the media over the last dozen years of transmania has kept hidden the entire concept of AGP from moody teenage girls, the main victims of trans social contagion.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
“Ex-men tend to be the Seal Team Six of Cancel Culture.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
Downfall
By 2024, survey data revealed a shift. Trans and nonbinary identifications among 18- to 22-year-olds fell 43 percent from 2022 levels. Jean M. Twenge's graphs by birth year showed the trend's youth confinement and decline. Growing evidence suggests this exposed the assumption as flawed, though debate continues. [1] Twenge's visuals further illustrated how transmania skipped older generations. This challenged claims of universal inner truths. [1] The Supreme Court upheld Tennessee's ban in a 6-3 decision. This marked a setback for youth medical transitions. [2] New York Times readers turned against the trans stance. The top 42 comments opposed the movement and its supporters. [2] In 2023, The White Lotus aired a monologue by Sam Rockwell's character. It went viral and boosted searches for autogynephilia. Ray Blanchard connected it to his theory. [3] Newsweek followed with an article explaining the concept. It covered Blanchard's work despite pushback from trans communities. [3]
▶ Supporting Quotes (6)
“Among American 18-22 year olds in 2022, 9.5% (eyeballed from this graph below) claimed trans or nonbinary identify in 2022 (6.3% trans and 3.2% nonbinary) vs. 5.4% (3.4% trans and 2.0% NB) in 2024, a decline of 43% in two years.”— Transmania: From Fad to Cringe
“Twenge also provides a graph of the fad not by calendar year but by birth year:”— Transmania: From Fad to Cringe
“The Supreme Court has upheld 6-3 Tennessee’s ban on sexual mutilation and poisoning of children.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“The 42 most popular comments in the New York Times are against the trans movement, the Biden Administration, Admiral Rachel Levine, the ACLU, and/or their ex-woman lead attorney Chase Strangio.”— Transmania Loses in the Supreme Court
“A four-minute scene from Sunday's episode of HBO's buzzy series "The White Lotus" has gone so viral that viewers are now simply calling it "that scene" as they discuss its meaning online.”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
“Newsweek writes, in a fine piece of reporting by Jesus Mesa: What Is Autogynephilia? 'White Lotus' Goes Where Few Have Dared”— "White Lotus" dares to go there
Sources
-
[1]
Transmania: From Fad to Cringereputable_journalism
- [2]
- [3]