Transgender Identity Warrants Leniency
False Assumption: Transgender identity should mitigate sentences for attempted political assassination.
Written by FARAgent on February 10, 2026
In 2022, Nicholas J. Roske traveled to Justice Brett Kavanaugh's home armed with a pistol, tactical gear, and zip ties. He told police his motives stemmed from the Uvalde school shooting, frustration over gun laws, and the leaked draft overturning Roe v. Wade. Roske, who later identified as a transgender woman named Sophie, faced charges for attempted assassination. Around this time, advocacy for transgender rights gained momentum in public policy, bolstered by academic work like a Georgetown Law Journal article arguing that terrorists could be rehabilitated like other offenders. This view influenced some legal circles, where identity factors began appearing in sentencing discussions.
Federal Judge Deborah Boardman, appointed by President Joe Biden in 2021, handled Roske's case. In October 2025, she sentenced Roske to 97 months in prison, citing mitigating factors including transgender identity and family acceptance struggles. Prosecutors had sought at least 30 years, but the lighter term could see Roske released in under a decade with good behavior. Critics pointed to this as evidence of undue leniency tied to identity politics.
The case has sparked debate among legal experts and commentators. Mounting evidence challenges the idea that transgender status should lighten sentences for violent crimes, with critics arguing it undermines equal justice. Supporters maintain that personal hardships deserve consideration in rehabilitation-focused sentencing. The issue remains hotly debated, as broader discussions on DEI in criminal justice continue.
People Involved
- In June 2022, Nicholas Roske drove from California to Maryland with plans to assassinate Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh. He had packed a gun, zip ties, and tactical gear.
- Roske turned himself in after pacing outside Kavanaugh's home. Later, he identified as a transgender woman named Sophie.
- Federal Judge Deborah Boardman, appointed by President Joe Biden, handled the case.
- She sentenced Roske to 97 months in prison, far below the guidelines of 360 months to life.
- Boardman cited Roske's transgender identity as a mitigating factor. She noted that the crime had prompted his family to accept their daughter.
- Boardman referred to him as Ms. Roske throughout the hearing.
- Roske had told police his motives stemmed from the Uvalde shooting, gun laws, and the overturning of Roe v. Wade. Critics argue this leniency, tied to transgender identity, raises questions about justice in political violence cases. [1][2]
▶ Supporting Quotes (5)
““I am heartened that this terrible infraction has helped the Roske family… accept their daughter for who she is,” Judge Boardman said.”— The Day of the Jackalette
““Ms. Roske came out to herself as transgender in 2020 but kept it secret. Ms. Roske’s sister came out as gay two years prior but Ms. Roske saw that their parents struggled to reconcile her sexuality with their religious beliefs.””— The Day of the Jackalette
“Judge Deborah Boardman, a Joe Biden appointee to Maryland federal court”— The Day of the Jackalette
“Justice Kavanaugh's would-be assassin, now renamed Sophie, gets a shorter sentence because Trump won't let him do his time in a women's prison.”— More Trans Terrorism
“The man, Nicholas J. Roske, had told the police he was upset about the deadly 2022 school shooting in Uvalde, Texas, and believed that Justice Kavanaugh would loosen gun control laws, prosecutors said. He also told the police that he was upset about a leaked draft of a Supreme Court opinion that revealed that the justices were poised to overturn Roe v. Wade, the landmark 1973 decision that guaranteed the right to an abortion.”— More Trans Terrorism
Organizations Involved
The U.S. District Court in Maryland became the stage for this sentencing in 2024. Under Judge Deborah Boardman, the court treated federal guidelines as advisory. It reduced the terrorism enhancement that would have mandated a harsher penalty. The hearing devoted over an hour to discussing Roske's transgender identity. This approach highlighted how institutional practices in the federal judiciary could incorporate identity considerations into decisions on attempted political assassinations. Growing questions surround whether such factors undermine the handling of domestic terrorism. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“The sentencing took more than seven hours, with much of the time dedicated to discussing how Roske’s transgender identity meant he should get a lighter sentence.”— The Day of the Jackalette
The Foundation
The assumption took root amid broader advocacy for transgender rights. Research from the Georgetown Law Journal suggested that terrorists might not be uniquely beyond rehabilitation. Judge Deborah Boardman drew on this to dismiss the full terrorism enhancement in Roske's case. She viewed standard rehabilitation as applicable even to domestic terrorism. Roske's struggles with family acceptance of his transgender identity were presented as mitigating the severity of plotting a political assassination. Elite promotion of transgenderism fostered the idea that such identities deserve special treatment in criminal justice. This seemed credible in progressive circles. Yet critics point to links with rising crimes involving transgender individuals, challenging the foundation. Mounting evidence questions whether gender identity struggles should outweigh assassination attempts. [1][2]
▶ Supporting Quotes (3)
““I have not seen evidence that the Sentencing Commission relied on evidence that it would reduce recidivism,” she said. She said recent research in the Georgetown Law Journal said terrorists are not uniquely incapable of being rehabilitated.”— The Day of the Jackalette
““I am heartened that this terrible infraction has helped the Roske family… accept their daughter for who she is,” Judge Boardman said.”— The Day of the Jackalette
“The enormous promotion of transgenderism over the last dozen years has led to an increasing share of the most heinous crimes — school shootings, Charlie Kirk’s assassination, the Zizian vegan Rationalist murder cult, etc. etc. — being committed by bad people with links to the transgender movement.”— More Trans Terrorism
How It Spread
Diversity, equity, and inclusion priorities shaped the Biden administration's judicial appointments. These influences appeared in Judge Deborah Boardman's sentencing, where she spent over an hour addressing Roske's gender identity. Media outlets like the New York Times covered Roske's political motives in detail. They focused on grievances over gun laws and abortion rights. Such reporting often downplayed connections to transgender identity. This helped spread the assumption amid wider cultural promotion of trans issues. Critics argue this selective framing sustains questionable leniency in serious crimes. The debate continues as dissenting voices highlight potential biases in propagation. [1][2]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“The story of the Biden-appointed DEI judgette who sentenced the ex-man who planned to kill Justice Brett Kavanaugh in 2022 to less than 30% of the standard term”— The Day of the Jackalette
“Here are the two most recent New York Times mentions of the would-be assassin of Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh: and, today: From last April’s NYT article:”— More Trans Terrorism
Resulting Policies
Federal sentencing guidelines, advisory since the 2005 Booker decision, allowed deviations in Roske's case. Judge Deborah Boardman imposed 97 months instead of the recommended 360 months to life for attempted assassination with a terrorism enhancement. She partially rejected the U.S. Sentencing Commission's terrorism provision. Boardman questioned its evidence base, despite Roske's plan to shift the Supreme Court's balance through murder. Placement in a women's prison posed challenges under a Trump-era policy restricting male-bodied transgender inmates. This influenced the shorter sentence tied to Roske's identity. Growing questions surround how such policies might encourage identity-based claims to reduce penalties for political violence. [1][2]
▶ Supporting Quotes (3)
“Boardman said “Under the law I must consider the sentencing guidelines. The guidelines in this case are 360 months to life. It’s important to understand the Supreme Court stance on guidelines… They used to be mandatory, but in [a case called] Booker the Supreme Court held that they were advisory.””— The Day of the Jackalette
“The judge acknowledged that “this crime did involve domestic terrorism,” but undid most of the “terrorism enhancement” created by the U.S. Sentencing Commission to increase recommended punishments in terrorism cases.”— The Day of the Jackalette
“Justice Kavanaugh's would-be assassin, now renamed Sophie, gets a shorter sentence because Trump won't let him do his time in a women's prison.”— More Trans Terrorism
Harm Caused
Roske's 97-month sentence meant potential release in as little as four years with good behavior. This fell well short of the 30-year minimum under full guidelines. Critics argue it weakens deterrence for attempts on Supreme Court justices' lives. The leniency, linked to transgender identity, reduced punishment for targeting a high court official. Mounting evidence challenges whether this approach harms public trust in handling political assassination plots. The case leaves room for debate on the true costs to justice and security. [1][2]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“He has been detained in the three years since, so with time served and good behavior, Roske’s sentence would mean he could be out four years after being sentenced on the charge of Attempt to Assassinate a U.S. Justice.”— The Day of the Jackalette
“Justice Kavanaugh's would-be assassin, now renamed Sophie, gets a shorter sentence because Trump won't let him do his time in a women's prison.”— More Trans Terrorism
Downfall
A Trump-era policy barred male-bodied transgender individuals from women's prisons. This complicated Roske's placement and contributed to his shorter sentence. Critics argue it exposed flaws in assuming transgender identity warrants broad leniency. Such limits highlight tensions in applying the assumption to serious crimes like attempted political assassination. Growing questions surround its viability, as dissenting voices point to these practical barriers. The issue remains contested, with evidence compellingly challenging the orthodoxy. [2]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“Justice Kavanaugh's would-be assassin, now renamed Sophie, gets a shorter sentence because Trump won't let him do his time in a women's prison.”— More Trans Terrorism
Sources
-
[1]
The Day of the Jackaletteopinion
-
[2]
More Trans Terrorismopinion