Gay Liberation Poses No Health Risks
False Assumption: Promoting open homosexuality and gay liberation in San Francisco would not lead to catastrophic public health consequences from promiscuity.
Written by FARAgent on February 10, 2026
In the 1970s, Harvey Milk rose as a gay rights activist in San Francisco. He opened Castro Camera as a political hub and won elections as America's first openly gay official. His movement turned Castro Street into a center of gay culture, featuring bathhouses and industrial-scale promiscuity.
This lifestyle amplified the spread of AIDS after HIV arrived. By 1993, AIDS had killed its 10,000th victim in San Francisco alone, making Castro the plague spot of the Western world. Biopics like 'Milk' omitted bathhouses, promiscuity, and the resulting catastrophe to maintain a hagiographic narrative.
Today, the role of promiscuous sex in gay communities in fueling the AIDS epidemic is widely recognized. Ship namings and films continue to honor Milk without context, but the health fallout broke the spell on unchecked liberation.
People Involved
- Harvey Milk arrived in San Francisco in the 1970s and pushed for gay liberation. He turned Castro Street into a center for open promiscuity. Milk had been discharged from the Navy for gay conduct on a ship. He ran a camera shop that doubled as a political hub, with little actual stock. [1]
- Jim Jones led the Peoples Temple cult and backed Milk's political campaigns. The two allied closely in the city's progressive circles. [1]
- Gus Van Sant directed the 2008 biopic 'Milk' and presented a cleaned-up version of the story. He left out the promiscuity and AIDS fallout. [1]
- Sean Penn starred as Milk and won an Oscar for it. Penn played him as overly effeminate, unlike Milk's real, more masculine demeanor. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (4)
“Milk’s gay liberation movement unleashed its own nemesis. Within two decades of Milk’s arrival, gay rights had transformed Castro Street into the plague spot of the Western world”— USNS Harvey Milk
“Milk’s alliance with Jim Jones’s Maoist Peoples Temple cult. Just ten days before Milk and Mayor George Moscone were murdered by working class politician Dan White, 907 ex-San Franciscans drank the Kool-Aid in Jonestown.”— USNS Harvey Milk
“Director Gus Van Sant (best remembered for 1989’s “Drugstore Cowboy”) manages to make even San Francisco look unattractive in his haste to get back to the gerrymandering at Milk’s camera shop.”— USNS Harvey Milk
“The acclaim that has greeted Penn’s supposedly precise impersonation of Milk is ironic because the 1984 documentary is readily viewable on Youtube, conveniently demonstrating how differently Milk and Penn read the same lines.”— USNS Harvey Milk
Organizations Involved
The Obama Administration decided in the 2010s to name a new class of Navy oilers after civil rights leaders. They included Harvey Milk in that list. The U.S. Navy followed through and launched the USNS Harvey Milk in 2021. This honored a man once kicked out for gay acts on a warship. [1] The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences gave Oscars to 'Milk' in 2009. They awarded Best Actor and Best Original Screenplay. The group endorsed the film's sanitized take on gay liberation. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (3)
“Back during the Great Awokening, the Obama Administration came up with the idea of naming the new class of oilers after civil rights leaders, such as Lucy Stone, Thurgood Marshall, Dolores Huerta, and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.”— USNS Harvey Milk
“Unusual for its class of namesakes, Milk at least served in the U.S. Navy (before getting kicked out for doing gay stuff on-board ship).”— USNS Harvey Milk
“The Academy even handed “Milk” the Best Original Screenplay award, although some of the drab script is lifted from “The Times of Harvey Milk,” which the Academy honored as Best Documentary back in 1984.”— USNS Harvey Milk
The Foundation
In the 1970s, Harvey Milk's camera shop looked like a serious business but held minimal inventory. Some said it served as a front for developing gay porn photos. This setup bolstered Milk's image as a committed activist while supporting the scene's promiscuity. [1] Media at the time painted gay liberation as entirely positive. They built the idea that bathhouse culture carried no dangers. Reports ignored how such spots would later spread AIDS. Experts and proponents assumed open homosexuality in San Francisco would bring no health crises. They were wrong. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“By the way, what kind of camera store is used as a political clubhouse? Camera shops are normally the worst meeting halls imaginable because they’re crammed with fragile and expensive merchandise. Yet, Milk’s “Castro Camera” is depicted as a shell with little inventory other than orange Kodak film boxes. (My guess: it was mostly a drop-off for amateur photographers who wanted their gay porn pictures developed discreetly -- an easy little business that left Milk with plenty of time on his hands for politics.)”— USNS Harvey Milk
“The bathhouses where the disease was spread aren’t shown. The movie is so politically prim that there’s only a single minute on the entire soundtrack of 1970s disco music.”— USNS Harvey Milk
How It Spread
Hollywood stepped in by 2008 with the biopic 'Milk'. The film won Oscars and reached wide audiences. It spread a heroic view of Harvey Milk and gay liberation. The story skipped over AIDS risks and ties to Jim Jones' cult. Media coverage amplified this narrative through reviews and promotions. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
““Milk” is a repetitious biopic about the 1970s political career of the self-proclaimed “Mayor of Castro Street” as Harvey Milk grinds through five election campaigns on his way to becoming “America’s first openly gay elected official.””— USNS Harvey Milk
Resulting Policies
Under President Obama, the Navy adopted a policy in the 2010s to name John Lewis-class oilers after civil rights icons. Harvey Milk made the cut. This approach continued into the Biden years, with renamings of ships linked to Confederates. The USNS Harvey Milk became a symbol of that shift. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“The USNS Harvey Milk is one of the John Lewis class of oilers. Back during the Great Awokening, the Obama Administration came up with the idea of naming the new class of oilers after civil rights leaders”— USNS Harvey Milk
Harm Caused
The promiscuous culture in Castro Street, boosted by Harvey Milk's efforts, fueled the AIDS epidemic. By 1993, the disease had killed 10,000 people in San Francisco. Bathhouses and open sexuality spread the virus rapidly. [1] Milk's alliance with Jim Jones added to the fallout. Jones's Peoples Temple ended in the Jonestown mass suicide of 907 in 1978, just before Milk's own death. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“with AIDS killing its 10,000th San Franciscan in 1993.”— USNS Harvey Milk
“Just ten days before Milk and Mayor George Moscone were murdered by working class politician Dan White, 907 ex-San Franciscans drank the Kool-Aid in Jonestown.”— USNS Harvey Milk
Downfall
The AIDS crisis hit San Francisco hard in the 1980s and exposed the flaws. It showed the health dangers of the promiscuous gay scene that Harvey Milk had promoted. Thousands died, proving the assumption wrong. [1] Later, viewers compared real footage of Milk to Sean Penn's role in the biopic. They saw the film's effeminate caricature did not match Milk's actual persona. This highlighted the story's distortions. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“A great tragic story could be made about how Milk’s gay liberation movement unleashed its own nemesis. Within two decades of Milk’s arrival, gay rights had transformed Castro Street into the plague spot of the Western world, with AIDS killing its 10,000th San Franciscan in 1993.”— USNS Harvey Milk
“Most strikingly, if “Milk’s” screenplay weren’t so relentlessly hagiographic, Sean Penn would be on the hot seat over his stereotypical caricaturizing of a homosexual. Penn’s performance is so flamingly effeminate”— USNS Harvey Milk
Sources
-
[1]
USNS Harvey Milkopinion