Contact Benefits Isolated Tribes
False Assumption: Contacting uncontacted tribes like the Sentinelese and integrating them into modern society improves their lives.
Written by FARAgent on February 11, 2026
Governments and nationalists pushed to contact isolated Andaman tribes to bring them into the mainstream. The British started in 1858 with a penal colony, introducing diseases. Indian authorities continued, planning to turn North Sentinel into a plantation in the late 20th century.
Other tribes suffered predictably after contact. The Jarawa gave up hostility recently, leading to rampant diseases like 50 percent Hepatitis B infection, AIDS, and rising violent crime. Andamanese Negritos overall were decimated by germs, with only North Sentinelese preserving their isolation through hostility and reefs.
Advocates like George Weber convinced authorities to protect North Sentinel. A 3-mile exclusion zone now bans outsiders. Missions stopped after Jarawa failures, though fools like the 2025 US tourist still try landing.
People Involved
- Triloknath Pandit, an Indian anthropologist, spent twenty-four years starting in 1967 trying to win the trust of the North Sentinelese. He left gifts and met them in 1991 before they turned him away for good. [1]
- George Weber, a Swiss scholar who founded the Andaman Association, warned against such contacts. He had seen other tribes ruined and pushed for leaving them alone. [1]
- Mykhailo Viktorovych Polyakov, a young American tourist, ignored the rules in 2025. He showed up on North Sentinel with a coconut and a Diet Coke. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (3)
“Indian anthropologist Triloknath Pandit worked for 24 years from 1967 to win the confidence of the islanders, leaving gifts for them on the beach while dodging their arrows... before finally peacefully meeting them in the shallows in 1991.”— North Sentinel Island News
“concerned Westerners such as Swissman George Weber took up the cause of the North Sentinelese.”— North Sentinel Island News
“Mykhailo Viktorovych Polyakov, 24, set foot on the restricted territory of North Sentinel... carrying a coconut and a can of Diet Coke.”— North Sentinel Island News
Organizations Involved
The Indian government pushed contact on other Andaman tribes. It even planned to convert North Sentinel into a plantation as part of its integration efforts. [1] The British set up a penal colony on the Andaman Islands in 1858. They brought in convicts and jailers, along with diseases that wiped out many Negritos. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“Back in the late 20th Century, the Indian government planned to land on North Sentinel and turn it into a plantation.”— North Sentinel Island News
“no outside group has succeeded in establishing a foothold there until in 1858, the British established a penal colony and introduced convicts, jailers and diseases.”— North Sentinel Island News
The Foundation
The assumption rested on a nationalist idea that pulling tribes into mainstream Indian society would help them. It sounded like progress for development, but ignored their lack of immunity to outside diseases. [1] The Andamanese had stayed isolated, making them easy targets for flu or measles, which could kill them off. Experts propped up contact as a way forward, wrongly assuming tribes would build immunity over time. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“'bring them into the mainstream of Indian society,' as the nationalist phrase has it.”— North Sentinel Island News
“They have been isolated from other people for a long time and have never had a chance to develop resistance against outside diseases... the common cold or an ordinary flu, let alone pneumonia, measles or venereal diseases, can be deadly to them.”— North Sentinel Island News
How It Spread
Government policies kept the idea alive. Officials sent VIP junkets dressed up as science missions to the islands. This went on until the Jarawa faced disaster from contact. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“'Missions of friendship' to the Sentineli have started only a few years ago. Just as with the Jarawa, most were junkets for visiting VIPs, camouflaged by being called 'scientific.'”— North Sentinel Island News
Resulting Policies
Indian authorities later changed course. They set up a three-mile exclusion zone around North Sentinel to keep diseases out and let the tribe live as they were. This reversed the old push for contact. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (1)
“All outsiders, Indians and foreigners alike, are banned from travelling within 3 miles (5km) of the island to protect the Indigenous people from outside diseases and to preserve their way of life.”— North Sentinel Island News
Harm Caused
The Jarawa tribe paid dearly after they stopped fighting outsiders. Half of them caught Hepatitis B, some got AIDS, and violent crimes rose. [1] The Andamanese Negritos as a whole got decimated by germs from the modern world, starting with the British penal colony. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“The latest reports received privately speak of 50 percent infection rate with Hepatitis B among Jarawas... There is AIDS among the Jarawa... violent crime is on the rise.”— North Sentinel Island News
“The Andamanese Negrito tribes have been decimated by contact with the modern world and its germs.”— North Sentinel Island News
Downfall
The assumption crumbled after the Jarawa suffered massive diseases from contact. That stopped any more missions to the Sentinelese. [1] A helicopter flyover after the 2004 tsunami showed the Sentinelese still thriving and ready to fight. It strengthened the case for protection. [1]
▶ Supporting Quotes (2)
“They were hurriedly aborted after the Jarawa catastrophe burst over the guilty administrators at Port Blair.”— North Sentinel Island News
“an Indian helicopter was sent to see if any Sentinelese had survived the December 26, 2004 tsunami and found the natives as feisty as ever.”— North Sentinel Island News
Sources
-
[1]
North Sentinel Island Newsreputable_journalism